mmvca
- Thread starter mmvca
- Start date
- Status
Re: mmvca
I have not spoken to anyone at the club today, in fact all i have heard about the loss of West Coburg points has been on this thread. So my opinions are certainly not representative of the club.
What i don't understand is why West Coburg is punished through the silly actions of one of its players? Allegedly a player played for another club in round 1, isn't it that club that benefited from his services and not West Coburg? West Coburg receive absolutely no advantage from this situation, unlike the one involving St Andrews playing an un-registered player.
I would have thought it common sense the club that benefited from the performance of the player should lose points for the game. Also, the player should be internally reprimanded by the Club, but i do not understand the logic behind punishing the club for an act which in no way benefits them and is a consequence of an individual.
mmvca;190488 said:
I have not spoken to anyone at the club today, in fact all i have heard about the loss of West Coburg points has been on this thread. So my opinions are certainly not representative of the club.
What i don't understand is why West Coburg is punished through the silly actions of one of its players? Allegedly a player played for another club in round 1, isn't it that club that benefited from his services and not West Coburg? West Coburg receive absolutely no advantage from this situation, unlike the one involving St Andrews playing an un-registered player.
I would have thought it common sense the club that benefited from the performance of the player should lose points for the game. Also, the player should be internally reprimanded by the Club, but i do not understand the logic behind punishing the club for an act which in no way benefits them and is a consequence of an individual.
banno36
Banned
Re: mmvca
Ah good, old West Coburg ey.
Always putting the team ahead of the individual.
You'll have to get a few outrights now Tuska!!! Just when everything was going rosy and the newspaper articles were appearing it has all fallen in a heap down Shore Reserve way.
Spewin we might not be able to watch the big choke this season.
Ah good, old West Coburg ey.
Always putting the team ahead of the individual.
You'll have to get a few outrights now Tuska!!! Just when everything was going rosy and the newspaper articles were appearing it has all fallen in a heap down Shore Reserve way.
Spewin we might not be able to watch the big choke this season.
monty
New Member
Re: mmvca
this is why you have registrations and clearances to stop players going around playing where they want,when they want. cricket is a team game,so the team/club is punished,not the individual. if this cricketer cared about his club he wouldn't do things like what has happened. also depending on the situation the other club involved might have to answer some questions reguarding rego and clearance
Redbacks;190497 said:
this is why you have registrations and clearances to stop players going around playing where they want,when they want. cricket is a team game,so the team/club is punished,not the individual. if this cricketer cared about his club he wouldn't do things like what has happened. also depending on the situation the other club involved might have to answer some questions reguarding rego and clearance
A
ALCOA
Guest
Re: mmvca
its a pretty big penalty to lose all your points, but i supopose they are the rules!! i heard they are going to appeal the decision.
its a pretty big penalty to lose all your points, but i supopose they are the rules!! i heard they are going to appeal the decision.
A
ALCOA
Guest
Re: mmvca
so can we take guesses at who the Gelnroy player was involved???
so can we take guesses at who the Gelnroy player was involved???
mmvca
Member
Re: mmvca
I think you will find that the club he played for in rnd 1, prob wont have anything to answer to, ( unless they are in this comp ) as im pretty sure you dont need a clearance to jump from 1 comp to another between seasons. But to come back to our comp, ( or any comp ) after you have started the season elsewhere and without a clearance, is just asking for trouble.
And i dont for one second believe that no-one at West Coburg knew of this.
monty;190598 said:
I think you will find that the club he played for in rnd 1, prob wont have anything to answer to, ( unless they are in this comp ) as im pretty sure you dont need a clearance to jump from 1 comp to another between seasons. But to come back to our comp, ( or any comp ) after you have started the season elsewhere and without a clearance, is just asking for trouble.
And i dont for one second believe that no-one at West Coburg knew of this.
A
ALCOA
Guest
Re: mmvca
Why are you keeping it a secret??
mmvca;190692 said:You can, but i wont be telling you who it is.
Why are you keeping it a secret??
bomber27
Member
Re: mmvca
As most people know who I am on this site, I won't name anybody because I'm not 100 per cent sure and only heard second hand. So I don't want to put anyone in.
Alcoa, have a think about it and come up with the most obvious name.
ALCOA;190806 said:Why are you keeping it a secret??
As most people know who I am on this site, I won't name anybody because I'm not 100 per cent sure and only heard second hand. So I don't want to put anyone in.
Alcoa, have a think about it and come up with the most obvious name.
1wkatatime
New Member
Re: mmvca
Any goss for this weeks games guys. Alot quieter this week in mmvca. Who made runs, who took wickets.
Any goss for this weeks games guys. Alot quieter this week in mmvca. Who made runs, who took wickets.
- Status