Opponent Voter & POTY

G

Goodbye

Guest
Opponent Voter & POTY

A flash of genius, or a load of **************** ?

Team POTY is good, how about standardising on it and making it the key to competition POTY.

Something like this:-
Captain and Vice Captain vote
Each team has a nominated voter that gives votes to the opponents in the game.
MOM by SIM gets votes.

I'd say that for tests 15 points each be distributed by the three voters 5 max per player. Sim MOM gets 3.
One Dayers 10 points each be distributed by the three voters 4 max per player. Sim MOM gets 2.

Season end we tally it up.

IMHO, tests are more important than one dayers so that's why test points would be higher.

Probably lot's of holes in it, but food for discussion.
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

I have no idea what you're talking about, so no.
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

Lmao, I also have no idea what he is talking about DK.

Perhaps make your suggestions a little bit more clear in future Frodo?

I still love you though.
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

I'm with the muppets on this one. Seems your trying to complicate the relative simple idea of having a POTY voted on by the captains.
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

If we could get something like this going would be interesting as long as players couldnt vote for themselves
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

Dirk Kuyt;228882 said:
I have no idea what you're talking about, so no.

For the benefit of the brain dead.

I'm firstly talking about 'team' POTY's. Look on bigfooty, most teams have a POTY competition, but in differing formats.

My idea is to standardise it and use the results for overall POTY.

Giving it to Captains sucks. Can they really vote for themselves? Or do they then vote for their love boy?

This system makes it fairer.

In addition it could possibly be used to help select international sides.
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

How about we just do it normally?

z0mg what a suggestion by myself1!!111!one1!1
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

ToonArmy;228927 said:
How about we just do it normally?

z0mg what a suggestion by myself1!!111!one1!1

What is normal?

On BFFCL each team does it differently!!
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

scottyD;228955 said:
So your saying the Team A votes on the best performers of Team B?
:confused:

No.
lets just take it as a club thing. Does your club want to have a player of the year? If so how will it be decided. Simplest is captain gives 3.2.1 points to best three players in a game.
I'm suggesting that if all teams follow a similar format then it should, at season end, show the best players in the competition. And that could be used for selecting the competition POTY.

I am suggesting also that maybe leaving it to the captain alone could be improved on, so Captain and Vice captain vote, along with a sensible member of the opposition. Then the SIM MOM gets to give a few points too.

Eg. Boncer is nominated Opponent Voter for Madrid. In a game against the Kings Fred Votes, I vote and Boncer Votes. 2 votes are added for the SIM MOM. They are then tallied and should give a decent appraisal of match performance.
Now this is a suggestion for discussion. Should an opponent vote, I don't know, but it is hard for voters to vote for themselves.

If we can get to this stage with understanding then we can discuss the points given.
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

Each club can run their own POTY. If the admin sees fit, at the end of the season, he can go over the games himself and make his own overall POTY. Simple
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

Dirk Kuyt;228998 said:
Each club can run their own POTY. If the admin sees fit, at the end of the season, he can go over the games himself and make his own overall POTY. Simple

z0mg what a suggestion 1!!one!1!11
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

Frodo;228963 said:
No.
lets just take it as a club thing. Does your club want to have a player of the year? If so how will it be decided. Simplest is captain gives 3.2.1 points to best three players in a game.
I'm suggesting that if all teams follow a similar format then it should, at season end, show the best players in the competition. And that could be used for selecting the competition POTY.

I am suggesting also that maybe leaving it to the captain alone could be improved on, so Captain and Vice captain vote, along with a sensible member of the opposition. Then the SIM MOM gets to give a few points too.

Eg. Boncer is nominated Opponent Voter for Madrid. In a game against the Kings Fred Votes, I vote and Boncer Votes. 2 votes are added for the SIM MOM. They are then tallied and should give a decent appraisal of match performance.
Now this is a suggestion for discussion. Should an opponent vote, I don't know, but it is hard for voters to vote for themselves.

If we can get to this stage with understanding then we can discuss the points given.
Why doesn't just the player with the most Man of the match awards win the Club POTY?
 
Re: Opponent Voter & POTY

Young Gun #6;229026 said:
Why doesn't just the player with the most Man of the match awards win the Club POTY?
Is one person per game sound right? They don't just have Best in say, a game of footy. They have 5 or 6 or however many. 1st would mean higher points and v-v
 
Back
Top