Barclay Shield 2017/18

Top Contributors
Right so 3 games will be 2 dayers and the other 2 are one dayers

Lucky for us boys as we were 4/30 odd
_Blackhawk_ said:
The rule is that if "more than 50%" of games didn't make the minimum of 20 overs, then the entire round is scrubbed that week for 1 day match day 2. I wonder what's happening with grades that had a 50/50 split, will they scrub the entire round of hold it to the letter of the rule and keep the 1st weeks result as not "more than" 50% of the games were washed out under 20 overs.
Click to expand...
ght so
 
Wouldn't it be great if the DVCA had a website (or social media site) and they posted something like this so we all knew what was going on.

With the weather interrupting play on Saturday the below is a summary of where all games currently sit as per rule S8:

Barclay Shield:
Riverside v Macleod 18.4 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Lower Eltham v Diamond Creek 21.1 overs bowled, play continues next week
NEW v Montmorency 25 overs bowled, play continues next week
OP'S v Epping 28 overs bowled, play continues next week
Bundoora v Rosanna 15.3 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week

Money Shield:
Less than 20 overs bowled in 4 games so all games revert to one day matches next week

Mash Shield:
Laurimar v Thomastown 19.5 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Greensborough v South Morang 14.1 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Panton Hill v Thomastown 36 overs bowled, play continues next week
Hurstbridge v Whittlesea 23 overs bowled, play continues next week

B Grade:
Epping v Bundoora United 19 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Macleod v Bundoora 24.5 overs bowled, play continues next week
Montmorency v Riverside 18 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Diamond Creek v Mernda 22.4 overs bowled, play continues next week

C Grade:
All matches reached 20 overs or more so play continues next week

D Grade:
Banyule v Greensborough 22.2 overs bowled, play continues next week
RECCC v Hurstbridge 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Thomastown United v Riverside 40 overs bowled, play continues next week
Plenty v Lower Plenty 25.1 overs bowled, play continues next week

E Grade:
All matches had less than 20 overs bowled so all games revert to a 1 day match next week

F1 Grade:
Whittlesea v OP Walkover to OP's
Bundoora v Banyule 17.4 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Rosanna v Eltham 24 overs bowled, play continues next week
Heidelberg v Macleod 19.4 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
As 2 out of the 3 matches failed to reach 20 overs all games revert to 1 day matches next week

F2 Grade:
All matches reached 20 overs or more so play continues next week

F3 Grade:
Mernda v Plenty 22 overs bowled, play continues next week
Epping v Rosanna 17.2 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
OP v Bundoora 28 overs bowled, play continues next week
Thomastown United v Thomastown 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week

G1 Grade:
Montmorency v Bye
Lalor Stars v Diamond Creek 25 overs bowled, play continues next week
Banyule v Lower Plenty 24.1 overs bowled, play continues next week
Macleod v RECCC 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week

G2 Grade:
Greensborough v Lower Eltham 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Riverside v Bye
Eltham v Laurimar Teal Walkover to Laurimar
South Morang v Laurimar Black 22 overs bowled, play continues next week

G3 Grade:
RECCC v Laurimar Teal 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Montmorency v Diamond Creek 16.5 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Macleod v Epping 20 overs bowled
Laurimar Black v South Morang 16.5 overs bowled
As 3 out of the 4 matches failed to reach 20 overs bowled all matches revert to 1 day games next week

G4 Grade:
Diamond Creek v Bye
Mill Park v RECCC 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Plenty v Hurstbridge 25 overs bowled, play continues next week
Panton Hill v Rosanna 22 overs bowled, play continues next week

For the games that revert to 1 day matches next week, MyCricket scores will be cleared and new teams can be selected providing players are not currently playing in a match or named in a team for a bye or walkover.
 
Well done Wanderunity, it's really not that difficult to write things like that, then post it. Although the DVCA seem to find it extremely challenging.

You should run for presidency of the whole comp. you'd get my vote, and BU already have a president in waiting to replace you. Blackhawk.:D
 
Tongs said:
Well done Wanderunity, it's really not that difficult to write things like that, then post it. Although the DVCA seem to find it extremely challenging.

You should run for presidency of the whole comp. you'd get my vote, and BU already have a president in waiting to replace you. Blackhawk.:D
Click to expand...

Calm down Tongs, I can’t take the credit. I simply C&P an email from the comp, but would have thought they could have done the same.

And the chair is a big one, but not sure it’s big enough for him....
 
WanderingUnity said:
Wouldn't it be great if the DVCA had a website (or social media site) and they posted something like this so we all knew what was going on.

With the weather interrupting play on Saturday the below is a summary of where all games currently sit as per rule S8:

Barclay Shield:
Riverside v Macleod 18.4 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Lower Eltham v Diamond Creek 21.1 overs bowled, play continues next week
NEW v Montmorency 25 overs bowled, play continues next week
OP'S v Epping 28 overs bowled, play continues next week
Bundoora v Rosanna 15.3 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week

Money Shield:
Less than 20 overs bowled in 4 games so all games revert to one day matches next week

Mash Shield:
Laurimar v Thomastown 19.5 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Greensborough v South Morang 14.1 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Panton Hill v Thomastown 36 overs bowled, play continues next week
Hurstbridge v Whittlesea 23 overs bowled, play continues next week

B Grade:
Epping v Bundoora United 19 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Macleod v Bundoora 24.5 overs bowled, play continues next week
Montmorency v Riverside 18 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Diamond Creek v Mernda 22.4 overs bowled, play continues next week

C Grade:
All matches reached 20 overs or more so play continues next week

D Grade:
Banyule v Greensborough 22.2 overs bowled, play continues next week
RECCC v Hurstbridge 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Thomastown United v Riverside 40 overs bowled, play continues next week
Plenty v Lower Plenty 25.1 overs bowled, play continues next week

E Grade:
All matches had less than 20 overs bowled so all games revert to a 1 day match next week

F1 Grade:
Whittlesea v OP Walkover to OP's
Bundoora v Banyule 17.4 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Rosanna v Eltham 24 overs bowled, play continues next week
Heidelberg v Macleod 19.4 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
As 2 out of the 3 matches failed to reach 20 overs all games revert to 1 day matches next week

F2 Grade:
All matches reached 20 overs or more so play continues next week

F3 Grade:
Mernda v Plenty 22 overs bowled, play continues next week
Epping v Rosanna 17.2 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
OP v Bundoora 28 overs bowled, play continues next week
Thomastown United v Thomastown 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week

G1 Grade:
Montmorency v Bye
Lalor Stars v Diamond Creek 25 overs bowled, play continues next week
Banyule v Lower Plenty 24.1 overs bowled, play continues next week
Macleod v RECCC 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week

G2 Grade:
Greensborough v Lower Eltham 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Riverside v Bye
Eltham v Laurimar Teal Walkover to Laurimar
South Morang v Laurimar Black 22 overs bowled, play continues next week

G3 Grade:
RECCC v Laurimar Teal 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Montmorency v Diamond Creek 16.5 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Macleod v Epping 20 overs bowled
Laurimar Black v South Morang 16.5 overs bowled
As 3 out of the 4 matches failed to reach 20 overs bowled all matches revert to 1 day games next week

G4 Grade:
Diamond Creek v Bye
Mill Park v RECCC 17 overs bowled reverts to 1 day match next week
Plenty v Hurstbridge 25 overs bowled, play continues next week
Panton Hill v Rosanna 22 overs bowled, play continues next week

For the games that revert to 1 day matches next week, MyCricket scores will be cleared and new teams can be selected providing players are not currently playing in a match or named in a team for a bye or walkover.
Click to expand...
great info, well done....however can never agree with a rule that 'clears the scores'. the weather will be what the weather will be, the 50% rule stinks, always has. This comp and other comps should be promoting playing cricket, not cancelling it or clearing the scores....if teams can get results where others cant, so be it
 
harry2bob said:
great info, well done....however can never agree with a rule that 'clears the scores'. the weather will be what the weather will be, the 50% rule stinks, always has. This comp and other comps should be promoting playing cricket, not cancelling it or clearing the scores....if teams can get results where others cant, so be it
Click to expand...

I don't mind the 50% rule, but maybe (and I'm only thinking out loud) an increase to the overs limit? Say 40 over mark would suit better. If you don't get at least half a days play in, then is it better to pull the pin, play a one day game next week with an outcome, rather than possible draws?
 
WanderingUnity said:
Calm down Tongs, I can’t take the credit. I simply C&P an email from the comp, but would have thought they could have done the same.

And the chair is a big one, but not sure it’s big enough for him....
Click to expand...
Thanks for that.

Some teams will be pretty happy with the outcome, others, maybe not...
 
I think the 20 overs is the right amount as far as constituting a game but I'd add to the 50% rule that once more than 50% of matches reach 20 overs then all matches in that grade will continue as a two day game. That way know one is advantaged or disadvantaged in anyway. Then it's up to the teams batting whether they can make a game of it or hold out for a draw. Everyone then has the same opportunity this week. I find that 3 games playing a 2 dayer and 2 games playing a 1 dayer isn't quite right(Barclay this week).
 
draught said:
I think the 20 overs is the right amount as far as constituting a game but I'd add to the 50% rule that once more than 50% of matches reach 20 overs then all matches in that grade will continue as a two day game. That way know one is advantaged or disadvantaged in anyway. Then it's up to the teams batting whether they can make a game of it or hold out for a draw. Everyone then has the same opportunity this week. I find that 3 games playing a 2 dayer and 2 games playing a 1 dayer isn't quite right(Barclay this week).
Click to expand...
its farcical..it longs odd to happen..but you have 3 games where potentially 10pts could be on offer and 2 where no 2nd innings is allowed....if the game starts and is weather effected...leave it up to captains to get a result...is a draw that bad really? would prefer a draw than cancelling actual overs played.
 
It's not so much the 10 points compared to 6points. It more that 2 games in Barclay are garaunteed a result where as 3 games could play out a draw! Unlikely thou with the game situations but that is irrelevant.
 
It's fairly obvious that most people on here will be playing for their respective clubs on the day and won't be able to attend, but let's try to get around this cause and support them any way you can. Donate something to raffle off, buy a couple of tickets even though you cannot attend, or simply donate. It's obviously a great charity, but this day is that bit more important for Gracie and the Money family. Best of luck to them all on the day.

Have a read and let's try to support them as best we can.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/leader/...y/news-story/23336e88c945d17a9c6740a8cf0a771e
 
Everyone sold on old paradians goin down after their win on the weekend? I can't see them winning 2 more.

Games Remaining:
7 Bundoora: DC, OP, NEW
8 Lower Eltham: NEW, ROS, MAC
9 North Eltham: LE, EPP, BUN
10 Old Paradians: MONT, BUN, ROS
 
Clive Rose said:
Everyone sold on old paradians goin down after their win on the weekend? I can't see them winning 2 more.

Games Remaining:
7 Bundoora: DC, OP, NEW
8 Lower Eltham: NEW, ROS, MAC
9 North Eltham: LE, EPP, BUN
10 Old Paradians: MONT, BUN, ROS
Click to expand...

Hope old paradians don’t get relegated. It would be a real shame.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top