Legend status
Member
Phil Crooks, Bill Anderson and Robert Young..
sounds like a real independent board if you ask me...
sounds like a real independent board if you ask me...
NMCA 2019/2020
- Thread starter spunout
- Start date
-
- Tags
- nmca north metro
Kermit
Member
If the correct decision was made in the first place then no appeal would have been required. Rivergum who finished second became the top seed after winning the first semi as per the rules. Socials and Footballers finished top and won their first semis as well. The rules state a premier must be awarded.
Common sense wins in the end.
Common sense wins in the end.
Yes No! Sorry
Active Member
All seems legit to me , As far as I'm aware ( happy to be corrected) none of those 3 have any links to the six clubs involved? If anything they'd be more inclined to side with the comp?
Well done to the 3 premiers, highest place teams won can't see any issue.
I'd doubt players would receive medals just a plaque to the club's one would think.
Well done to the 3 premiers, highest place teams won can't see any issue.
I'd doubt players would receive medals just a plaque to the club's one would think.
They being very independent in my views. What being the problem. Move on dear sir.
Pauline Hanson
New Member
If true and 2 of those 3 ‘independent’ individuals were involved to deliberate the outcome then you don’t have to be Einstein to work out the value of the Premiership title is worthless. Bill & Phil would only need a can of free piss to influence their decision but then they are typical of this comp!Lucky the mafia are moving on as no doubt there would have been more to come.
Anyway hearing we still dont have enough umps for the season, anyone got anymore on this?
Anyway hearing we still dont have enough umps for the season, anyone got anymore on this?
Yes No! Sorry
Active Member
I'd be more concerned about having an actual season first Pauline.
Ps. You sound like a real bitter ********
Ps. You sound like a real bitter ********
Kermit
Member
They were influenced by the rules. Wouldn’t be hard to comprehend if you read them.
Why has it taken this long to make a decision If the rules were so clear. There’s rules for everything except pandemics.
Yes No! Sorry
Active Member
Maybe there's been a few more things of higher importance happening , who cares how long it's taken.
Kermit
Member
Maybe bring that up at the next board meeting
Pauline Hanson
New Member
Yep you winners are spot on...I am absolutely shattered and bitter that I/we cannot celebrate being ‘gifted’ a premiership for an event that didn’t occur. You enjoy your victory laps/drinks....not sure if more laughable or embarrassing but hey keep defending your 2020 titles!!
Banter2020
New Member
Are you from one of the 3 teams on the other side of this verdict ?
Banter2020
New Member
If you were in the position that the 3 teams who were awarded the premierships im sure your take on it would be different , dont you think ?
Pauline Hanson
New Member
For the recorded we finished out of the top 4 as we do most seasons!
The comp needs to be brought to account on how and what has lead to them reversing their original decision after publicly declaring their position months ago of not awarding any title winners and then to arrive at this position is astounding.
If the 3 awarded clubs want to hang their hats on claiming the Premiership title, then GL to them.
The comp needs to be brought to account on how and what has lead to them reversing their original decision after publicly declaring their position months ago of not awarding any title winners and then to arrive at this position is astounding.
If the 3 awarded clubs want to hang their hats on claiming the Premiership title, then GL to them.
Banter2020
New Member
A decision 6 months later......Comp is the laughing stock. I don’t have an issue with the decision either way. But really..... its a wonder this comp is on the canvas & the panel is not independent. Make a decision according to the rules at the time, no issue with that. No rules have chance since. I think there are agendas all over the place. Cricket Vic can only fix the sinking ship.
We have the”star” to fixing our problems now. In the STAR we trust.