Cleanprophet
Active Member
You can't use a net, or have a bucket of balls, or bowl without a batsman present either.
I don't accept that practice conditions need or indeed should for a great part match those of the competitive situation, and the general way to learn skills is to master them at favourable conditions and then increase the difficulty. That's why you don't ski down a black run first time out. It's why you don't windsurf in a howling gale until you have had a great deal of experience. It's why boxers might practice punching bags that don't hit back. It's why high wire walkers will first practice with a net below them. etc
It depends on what you are netting for. For out-and-out technical stuff, you can just go for it with a set of stumps. But, the main reason a top spinner takes wickets is because of his ability to figure out a batsman and stay one step ahead of him. So, really useful and effective match practice requires that you bowl to a batter.
The issue with using something like Rosin on your fingers is that once you get into a match you won't have it available to you. So, if your problem isn't technical but simply a traction problem, then you need to find a solution that is applicable in the nets and in a match. As I say, the best option is use saliva and maybe have something sweet and sugary in your mouth so that your saliva makes your hands sticky. That is something you could get away with in a match.