South Africa in Australia

Top Contributors
Re: South Africa in Australia

Frigging hell. Just pick two bowlers, Ponting. Fair enough they're not doing that well, but swapping them around isn't helping anyone get into a rhythm.
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

Quality delivery would of knocked over a healthy Smith possibly.

Hauritz is just terrible, Ricky had no imagination and Hayden is done and dusted.

Great series even though we got done.

Bring on the 20-20's and ODI
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

D.K;305717 said:
Great series even though we got done.
Click to expand...
QFT. Haven't enjoyed a series as much since the 2005 Ashes. Every game was brilliant, edge of your seat stuff.

First crack at my team of the series:

Smith
Katich
Ponting
de Villiers
Duminy
Clarke
Haddin
Johnston
Steyne
Siddle
Ntini

Ponting and Amla was a bit of a toss-up for me... that was a bit of a toss-up, Amla more consistent but Ponting made the big runs. Haddin's batting was a lot better than Boucher's, although I think the Protea kept slightly better.

EDIT: Switched Harris for Siddle. No spinners in my team, but really nobody earned it.
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

Caesar;305721 said:
QFT. Haven't enjoyed a series as much since the 2005 Ashes. Every game was brilliant, edge of your seat stuff.

My first crack at team of the series:

Smith
Katich
Ponting
De Villiers
Duminy
Clarke
Haddin
Johnston
Steyne
Harris
Ntini

Ponting and Amla was a bit of a toss-up for me... that was a bit of a toss-up, Amla more consistent but Ponting made the big runs. Haddin's batting was a lot better than Boucher's, although I think the Protea kept slightly better. Harris... not sure he should be there. Tempting to replace him with Siddle.
Click to expand...

Mine would have to be.

Smith (c)
Katich
Ponting
A.B
Clarke
Duminy
Haddin
Johnson
Steyn
Siddle
Ntini
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

D.K;305722 said:
Mine would have to be.

Smith (c)
Katich
Ponting
A.B
Clarke
Duminy
Haddin
Johnson
Steyn
Siddle
Ntini
Click to expand...
You're right, Siddle deserved it more than Harris, who was a nonentity. I rethought it, but didn't get to the post in time. :p
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

Caesar;305724 said:
You're right, Siddle deserved it more than Harris, who was a nonentity. I rethought it, but didn't get to the post in time. :p
Click to expand...

Siddle was only slightly more interesting then watching Hauritz and paint dry/grass grow reallly.

Krezja would of been in there for sure if the selctors had some balls after the first test and stuck with an attacking option insted of a runs container. If my memory served me correctly I am sure we needed to attack and win not defend and draw.

I reckon the BigCricket community could do a better job of being Chairman of Selectors then the muppet who is there now.
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

Hayden is just embarassing himself now, be the bigger man and retire mate, you aren't doing anyone any favours.

That was an absolute dolly.
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

What a great finish to an exciting test series , if matches like these happens often then test cricket will survive for longer years
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

Quality call by Nicholas. "Who's likely to survive an over, Smith with a broken hand or Ntini?"

:D
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

Ljp86;305296 said:
The South African batting order is pretty well set so tinkering with it is not in their best interests. Morkel opened because South Africa didn't want to switch around their top six which probably wasn't the right thing to do considering they have nunerous opening options.

Morkel was a sacrificial wicket more then anything and was unlikely to score anything significant should he have batted in his usual spot on day five.
Click to expand...

Morkel is getting paid to bowl and the batsman are getting paid to bat. they've got two blokes in that side who have opened the batting before in international cricket and another bloke who has opened in first class cricket. Surely they would've been better options to face the new ball with a rested fired up attack with 15 overs to go in the days play than a bloke who can't spell bat and has bowled his guts on a pretty hot day.

Great game of cricket, great series. In the top 3 series I have seen alongside 2005 Ashes and Aus tour of India in 2001. Smith, one the most courageous acts i have seen in a sporting field. Very deserved player of the series.
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

Poor old Bollinger. He really needed something special this innings, and he's been cheated of a couple of wickets now.
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

What a series !
Well done to all parties.

Will be interesting to see the follow up series in South Africa and as well as the up coming 20 20s and odis.

What a gutsy effort by Smith I am sure on this day the team if they haven't already will appreciate and acknowledge the gutsy skipper they had.
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

The430king;305975 said:
Morkel is getting paid to bowl and the batsman are getting paid to bat. they've got two blokes in that side who have opened the batting before in international cricket and another bloke who has opened in first class cricket. Surely they would've been better options to face the new ball with a rested fired up attack with 15 overs to go in the days play than a bloke who can't spell bat and has bowled his guts on a pretty hot day.

Great game of cricket, great series. In the top 3 series I have seen alongside 2005 Ashes and Aus tour of India in 2001. Smith, one the most courageous acts i have seen in a sporting field. Very deserved player of the series.
Click to expand...

As much as I agree with you, the South African "Think Tank" didn't see it that way. It was a silly thing to do in hindsight as South Africa were always going to be one down early (two if Smith didn't bat). They probably should have opened with McKenzie and Amla, putting Kallis at three and then de Villiers at four.

South Africa will run into a problem should McKenzie's poor form continue though, they will then have to make a choice on who opens with Smith. Do they bring Prince back in and bump either Amla, de Villiers or Duminy into the opening spot or do they bring in another specialist opener, a Herschelle Gibbs perhaps?
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

Frigging hell. Just pick two bowlers, Ponting. Fair enough they're not doing that well, but swapping them around isn't helping anyone get into a rhythm.
 
Re: South Africa in Australia

Squads for 20/20 and one day series.

The KFC Twenty20 squad is:

R. Ponting (c): TAS, 34
M. Hussey (vc): WA, 33
D. Hussey: VIC, 31
B. Hilfenhaus: TAS, 25
J. Hopes: QLD, 30
N. Bracken: NSW, 31
B. Haddin: NSW, 31
S. Marsh: WA, 25
S. Tait: SA, 25
D. Warner: NSW, 22
R. Harris: QLD, 29
C. White: VIC, 25
N. Hauritz: NSW, 27

The Commonwealth Bank Series squad is:

R. Ponting (c): TAS, 34
M. Clarke (vc): NSW, 27
B. Haddin: NSW, 31
J. Hopes: QLD, 30
N. Bracken: NSW, 31
S. Marsh: WA, 25
M. Hussey: WA, 33
D. Hussey: VIC, 31
N. Hauritz: NSW, 27
B. Hilfenhaus: TAS, 25
C. White: VIC, 25
S. Tait: SA, 25
P. Siddle: VIC, 24

Commenting on the selection of the squads, NSP Chairman Andrew Hilditch said:

“The announcement of these squads for the KFC Twenty20 Internationals and the Commonwealth Bank Series is a clear indication we are now in full-scale planning for the 2009 ICC World Twenty20 and the 2011 ICC World Cup.

“Winning a fourth consecutive ICC World Cup and our first ICC Twenty20 title is an ambitious project. For this reason there will be very few players selected from this point that we can not see playing a role in achieving this goal.

“The omission of Matthew Hayden from the KFC Twenty20 and Commonwealth Bank Series squads is not a reflection on his performances in the recent Test series but rather a strategic decision made by the National Selection Panel as we plan for these signature events. His possible selection for the upcoming tour of South Africa will be discussed as with all players when we select a squad after the round of interstate matches at the beginning of February.

“New South Wales opener David Warner has been selected in the KFC Twenty20 squad after some eye-catching performances particularly this year. He adds a dynamic nature to the top of the order and we look forward to seeing his performances at the international level.

“Queensland all-rounder Ryan Harris has also been added to the squad for the KFC Twenty20 games. Ryan has had a very good season for Queensland and has the ability to swing the ball at good pace. He is also very good in the field and handy with the bat and it will be interesting to see his progress in these two matches.

“Mitchell Johnson will not take part in the two KFC Twenty20 matches or first two of the Commonwealth Bank Series matches. It has been advised by team medical and fitness staff that due to his workload over the last few months he should continue to be monitored. For this reason he will not be available for selection in these matches.

“Nathan Hauritz has been added to both the KFC Twenty20 and Commonwealth Bank Series squads after some impressive performances in interstate one-day cricket over several seasons. While we have not selected a specialist spinner in these forms of the game recently, it will be nice to have the flexibility of a specialist spinner when necessary.

“It is exciting for Australian cricket that Shaun Tait has been selected in both the KFC Twenty20 and Commonwealth Bank Series squads. Although he has had some injury problems since playing a leading role in the 2007 ICC World Cup, he is an explosive weapon at his best and we hope he will play a key role in both forms of the game this summer,” Hilditch concluded.

Commenting on Michael Clarke’s unavailability for the KFC Twenty20 International games, Australian team physiotherapist Alex Kountouris said:

“Michael Clarke suffered some ligament damage to his right thumb during the first 3 Mobile Test against South Africa in Perth. This injury has required pain killing injections in every batting innings since and for this reason we have decided the best course of action is for him to miss the first two KFC Twenty20 matches. We will continue to monitor the injury over the next four to five days and we are very hopeful of him being fully fit for the beginning of the Commonwealth Bank Series.”
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top